The conventional wisdom is clear: put down payment 20 percent on a house to avoid PMI and get the best rates. Your parents said it. Your financial advisor probably mentioned it. But this advice, while not wrong, misses something crucial—the opportunity cost of locking up that much cash in your home’s walls.
The Real Cost of the 20% Rule
Let’s say you’re buying a $400,000 home. A 20% down payment means $80,000 upfront. A 10% down payment is $40,000. That $40,000 difference isn’t just sitting in your bank account waiting to be spent—it’s capital that could be working for you elsewhere.
PMI typically costs between 0.5% and 1.5% of your loan amount annually. On a $320,000 loan (with 20% down), you’d pay zero PMI. On a $360,000 loan (with 10% down), you might pay around $150-300 per month until you hit 20% equity. That sounds expensive until you run the actual numbers.
If you invested that $40,000 difference at a historically average 7% return, you’d earn roughly $2,800 in the first year alone. Your PMI might cost $2,400-3,600 annually. The gap is smaller than most people assume—and in some scenarios, investing wins outright.
According to Freddie Mac, the average PMI rate for borrowers with good credit putting 10% down is around 0.58% of the loan amount annually. That’s not the financial catastrophe it’s often portrayed as.
When 20% Down Actually Makes Sense
The 20% down payment isn’t a scam—it’s just not universally optimal. Here’s when it genuinely works in your favor:
You’re in a competitive market. Sellers and their agents view larger down payments as signals of financial strength. In bidding wars, a 20% down offer often beats a 10% down offer, even at the same price. The perception of reliability matters when sellers are choosing between multiple offers.
You have a lower credit score. PMI costs scale with risk. If your credit score is below 700, your PMI rates could jump to 1.5% or higher. At that point, the math shifts dramatically toward putting more down.
You’re already maxing out retirement accounts. If your 401(k) and IRA are fully funded, and you have a healthy emergency fund, that extra cash doesn’t have an obvious better use. Reducing your mortgage balance is a guaranteed return equal to your interest rate.
You hate debt psychologically. Personal finance isn’t purely mathematical. If carrying a larger mortgage keeps you awake at night, the peace of mind from a bigger down payment has real value—even if the spreadsheet says otherwise.
You’re buying in a flat or declining market. When home prices aren’t appreciating—or worse, are falling—a larger down payment provides crucial equity cushion. Starting with 20% equity means you can weather a 10% price decline without going underwater. With only 10% down, even a modest correction could leave you owing more than your home is worth.
When a Smaller Down Payment Wins
The scenarios where putting less than 20% down makes more sense are more common than the conventional wisdom suggests:
You’d drain your emergency fund. Buying a house with $80,000 down and $5,000 left in savings is a recipe for disaster. Homes break. Jobs disappear. A smaller down payment that leaves you with 6-12 months of expenses is often the smarter play. The average homeowner spends 1-2% of their home’s value annually on maintenance and repairs—on a $400,000 home, that’s $4,000-8,000 per year you need to have accessible.
You’re in a rapidly appreciating market. If home prices in your area are climbing 5-8% annually, getting into the market sooner with a smaller down payment captures that appreciation. Waiting another two years to save the full 20% could cost you more than the PMI you’d avoid. On a $400,000 home appreciating at 6% per year, that’s $24,000 in equity you’d miss in year one alone—far more than any PMI payment.
Your mortgage rate is low. When mortgage rates are below 4-5%, the opportunity cost of tying up cash in home equity becomes painful. That money could earn more in index funds than you’re saving on interest—especially when you factor in the mortgage interest deduction.
You have high-interest debt. Putting 20% down while carrying credit card balances at 22% APR is financial self-harm. Pay off the high-interest debt first, even if it means a smaller down payment and paying PMI for a few years.
You’re young with decades of compounding ahead. A 30-year-old who invests $40,000 instead of putting it toward a larger down payment could see that money grow to over $300,000 by retirement at historical stock market returns. The earlier in life you face this decision, the more the opportunity cost of a large down payment matters.
For more on balancing mortgage decisions with other financial priorities, see why a jumbo loan might cost you more than you think and what nobody tells you about private mortgage insurance.
The PMI Escape Hatch Most People Forget
Here’s what the 20% down evangelists often skip: PMI isn’t permanent. Once you reach 20% equity—through payments, appreciation, or both—you can request PMI cancellation. At 22% equity, lenders must automatically remove it.
In a market where homes appreciate 4-5% annually, a buyer who puts 10% down can build equity surprisingly fast. With 10% down on a $400,000 home, you start with $40,000 in equity. At 5% annual appreciation, your home gains $20,000 in value the first year, bringing your equity to roughly $60,000 (plus principal payments). By the end of year two, appreciation alone has added another $21,000, putting you close to the $80,000 threshold for 20% equity. Combined with principal payments of roughly $4,000-5,000 per year in the early years of a 30-year mortgage, most buyers in appreciating markets can request PMI removal within 2-3 years.
You can also refinance once you hit 20% equity, which removes PMI and potentially locks in a better rate. This strategy works particularly well if you buy when rates are high and refinance when they drop.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau outlines your rights around PMI cancellation—rights that many borrowers don’t fully understand. You have the right to request cancellation at 20% equity, and your lender must honor that request if you’re current on payments and have a good payment history.
The Hidden Costs on Both Sides
The down payment decision involves trade-offs that extend beyond the obvious PMI calculation.
Costs of putting 20% down:
- Reduced liquidity for emergencies, opportunities, or life changes
- Opportunity cost of foregone investment returns
- Potential delay in entering the market while saving
- More financial eggs in one basket (your home)
Costs of putting less than 20% down:
- Monthly PMI payments until you reach 20% equity
- Slightly higher interest rates in some cases
- Less equity cushion if home values decline
- Higher total interest paid over the life of the loan (due to larger loan amount)
Neither choice is inherently wrong. The right answer depends on your complete financial picture, not just the down payment in isolation.
A Simple Framework for Your Decision
Stop asking “should I put 20% down?” and start asking these questions instead:
-
After the down payment, will I have at least 6 months of expenses saved? If no, consider putting less down. Homeownership without a safety net is a gamble you don’t want to take.
-
What’s my PMI rate based on my credit score and down payment? Get actual quotes, not estimates. The difference between 0.5% and 1.5% PMI changes everything. A buyer with a 760 credit score pays dramatically less PMI than someone at 680.
-
What would I do with the extra cash if I put less down? If the answer is “probably spend it,” the 20% down payment is forced savings. If the answer is “invest in index funds” or “pay off 18% APR credit cards,” do the math.
-
How long do I plan to stay in this house? If you’re confident you’ll be there 10+ years, minimizing monthly payments through a larger down payment makes more sense. If you might move in 5 years, flexibility matters more.
-
What’s my risk tolerance? A larger down payment means more equity but less liquidity. A smaller down payment preserves optionality but increases monthly costs.
-
What’s happening in my local housing market? In rapidly appreciating markets, getting in sooner matters more. In flat or uncertain markets, the equity cushion of 20% down provides valuable protection.
The Question Nobody Asks
Most people obsess over the down payment percentage while ignoring a more important question: should you buy at all right now, or rent and invest the difference?
If you’re stretching to hit 20% down, that might be a signal that you’re not financially ready for homeownership—regardless of what percentage you put down. The down payment is just one piece of a much larger financial puzzle that includes maintenance costs, property taxes, insurance, and the opportunity cost of illiquid equity.
Consider this: a $400,000 home with property taxes of 1.2%, insurance at $2,000 per year, and maintenance at 1.5% costs roughly $14,000 annually before you make a single mortgage payment. That’s money you need to budget for regardless of your down payment size.
The 20% rule isn’t wrong. It’s just incomplete. Your optimal down payment depends on your credit score, your local market, your risk tolerance, your alternative uses for that capital, and a dozen other factors that generic advice can’t account for.
Run the numbers for your specific situation. The answer might surprise you.