You closed on your mortgage twelve months ago, and now you’re wondering whether it’s time to refinance after one year. Maybe rates dropped. Maybe your credit score improved. Maybe you’re just tired of that PMI payment eating into your budget every month. The temptation to act quickly is real—but so are the costs of getting this decision wrong.
The truth is, refinancing after just one year can be brilliant or disastrous, and the difference comes down to math most people never bother to run.
The break-even calculation nobody explains properly
Here’s what lenders won’t emphasize: every refinance comes with closing costs, typically 2% to 5% of your loan amount. On a $300,000 mortgage, that’s $6,000 to $15,000 out of pocket or rolled into your new loan.
The break-even point is when your monthly savings exceed what you paid to refinance. If you’re saving $200 per month and paid $8,000 in closing costs, you need 40 months just to break even. Refinance after one year, then move or refinance again in two years? You lost money.
But here’s the twist: if you’re eliminating PMI, your effective savings might be much higher than the rate reduction alone suggests. PMI typically runs 0.5% to 1% of your loan amount annually. On that $300,000 loan, that’s $1,500 to $3,000 per year you could eliminate if you’ve hit 20% equity.
When refinancing after one year actually makes sense
The one-year mark isn’t arbitrary. Most lenders require you to wait at least six months before refinancing, and some loan types have longer “seasoning” requirements. FHA loans, for example, require at least 210 days and six payments before a streamline refinance. But meeting the minimum doesn’t mean you should refinance.
Refinancing after one year works when:
- Interest rates have dropped at least 0.75% to 1% from your current rate
- You plan to stay in the home for at least 4-5 more years
- Your credit score has improved significantly (50+ points), qualifying you for better terms
- You can eliminate PMI by reaching 20% equity through appreciation or principal paydown
- You’re switching from an adjustable-rate mortgage before the adjustment period hits
It backfires when:
- You’re only saving $50-100 per month but paying $8,000+ in closing costs
- You plan to move within 2-3 years
- You’re restarting a 30-year term and adding years of interest payments
- You’re rolling closing costs into the loan, increasing your total debt
The hidden cost of resetting your amortization schedule
This is where early refinancing gets dangerous. After one year of payments on a 30-year mortgage, you’ve barely touched your principal. Most of your payments went straight to interest.
When you refinance into a new 30-year loan, you reset the clock entirely. You’re now looking at 31 years of total payments instead of 30. Even if your monthly payment drops, you might pay tens of thousands more in total interest over the life of the loan.
Let’s put real numbers to this. Say you have a $300,000 loan at 7% and refinance after one year to 6.25%. Your monthly payment drops from $1,996 to $1,847—a savings of $149 per month. Sounds great until you realize you’ve added a year back onto your loan. Over 30 years at the new rate, you’ll pay approximately $365,000 in total interest. If you’d kept your original loan for the remaining 29 years, you’d have paid roughly $394,000 more in interest from that point—so yes, you save money, but only about $29,000 net after accounting for the extra year of payments.
The fix? Consider refinancing into a shorter term. If you can afford similar payments, a 15-year or 20-year mortgage after one year of a 30-year loan might cost you less per month than you think—especially if rates have dropped—while dramatically reducing your total interest paid.
According to Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey, the spread between 30-year and 15-year rates typically runs 0.5% to 0.75%. That difference compounds significantly over time.
What your lender won’t tell you about closing costs
Lenders love advertising “no-closing-cost” refinances. What they don’t love explaining is that those costs don’t disappear—they get baked into your interest rate instead.
A no-closing-cost refinance might offer you 6.5% instead of 6.0%. Over 30 years on a $300,000 loan, that 0.5% difference costs you about $38,500 extra in interest (roughly $107 more per month over 360 payments). You just paid closing costs anyway—spread out and invisible.
For a one-year refinance, sometimes the no-closing-cost option actually makes sense. If you’re uncertain how long you’ll stay, avoiding upfront costs reduces your risk. But if you’re committed to the home long-term, paying closing costs upfront for a lower rate almost always wins.
The PMI elimination strategy
If you put less than 20% down on your original purchase, PMI is probably your biggest motivator for refinancing early. Here’s how to think about it:
Option A: Wait for automatic PMI removal. Under the Homeowners Protection Act of 1998, your lender must cancel PMI when your loan balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price. Note: this is based on the original value, not current market value.
Option B: Request early removal at 80% loan-to-value. Most lenders allow this, but they’ll require an appraisal at your expense. According to the Appraisal Institute, typical home appraisal costs now range from $400 to $800 in most markets, with higher costs in expensive metro areas. You’ll also need to be current on payments with a good payment history.
Option C: Refinance into a new loan without PMI. If your home has appreciated significantly, you might qualify for a conventional loan at 80% LTV even if you haven’t paid down much principal. This resets your rate, potentially lowers your payment, and eliminates PMI all at once.
Option C makes sense when rates have dropped AND your home has appreciated. If only one of those conditions is true, run the numbers carefully before committing. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends getting loan estimates from at least three lenders to compare true costs.
The credit score factor most people underestimate
Your credit score at purchase might have been good enough to qualify, but not good enough to get the best rates. After a year of on-time mortgage payments, many borrowers see their scores jump 20 to 50 points or more.
That improvement matters more than you might think. According to data from mortgage rate surveys, the difference between a 680 credit score and a 740+ score can mean 0.5% or more on your interest rate. On a $300,000 loan, that translates to roughly $90 per month—or over $32,000 across a 30-year term.
If your score has climbed into a higher tier since you bought, refinancing after one year could lock in substantially better terms even if market rates haven’t moved much. Pull your credit reports from all three bureaus before applying, and dispute any errors that might be dragging down your score.
A simple framework for your decision
Before calling your lender, answer these questions:
-
What’s my break-even point? Divide total closing costs by monthly savings. If the answer is longer than your expected time in the home, stop here.
-
Am I extending my loan term? If yes, calculate total interest paid over the remaining original term versus the new term. The monthly savings might not be worth decades of extra payments.
-
What’s my real motivation? Rate reduction, PMI elimination, cash-out, or switching loan types all have different math. Don’t refinance for 0.25% rate reduction if your real goal is eliminating PMI—there might be a cheaper path.
-
Can I get a shorter term for similar payments? This is the question most borrowers skip. A 20-year or 15-year refinance after one year often costs less monthly than people assume.
-
Have I shopped multiple lenders? Closing costs and rates vary significantly. The CFPB found that borrowers who get quotes from multiple lenders save an average of $300 per year on their mortgage.
The bottom line on early refinancing
Refinancing after one year isn’t inherently good or bad—it’s a math problem with emotional complications. The lure of a lower payment is powerful, but it can mask the reality of extended loan terms and hidden costs.
If rates have dropped significantly, your credit has improved, or you can eliminate PMI while locking in a better rate, refinancing at the one-year mark can save you tens of thousands over the life of your loan. But if you’re chasing marginal savings, planning to move soon, or simply restarting a 30-year clock, you’re likely paying for the privilege of feeling like you got a deal.
Run the break-even calculation. Consider the full cost of extending your term. And remember: the best refinance is the one you don’t need to refinance again in another year.
If you’re also weighing whether to put extra payments toward your mortgage versus investing, or wondering about the real cost of choosing a HELOC over a home equity loan, those decisions connect directly to your refinancing strategy. The money you save—or waste—on a refinance affects every other financial choice you make with your home.